Best Toaster Ovens 2017 – Buyer’s Guide

Before We Dive Deep and See Our Top Toaster Oven Reviews…

using a toaster oven to make chicken wingsThey may call it a toaster, but a toaster oven can do way more than just turn bread into crisp, golden toast. Today’s toasters can be used for cooking as well as for toasting, and they come in a variety of sizes and styles to suit every home cook’s needs.

While you won’t find a shortage of styles online, you may struggle to know which models out of the hundreds available are really the best toaster ovens.

The truth is that there isn’t one particular appliance that will be the best choice for everyone. You’ll need to consider a number of factors to determine which one will fit into your kitchen and your life the best.

In keeping with the subject of fit, you need to make sure that the toaster you buy won’t take up all of the space on your counter. At the same time, you want to have enough room for cooking inside. Toasters are usually measured by slice size. Two-slice models are the smallest and tend to be about 16 inches by 8 or 9 inches, making them less than ideal for cooking most foods. The biggest models will usually hold 6 or 8 slices and may be large enough to cook a 12 or 16-inch pizza.

Another important thing to consider is how easy the toaster will be to use and maintain. Some models have auto eject racks that allow you to get food out without burning your fingers and removable crumb trays that simplify cleanup.

When you’re considering your options, it’s a good idea to think about exactly what you want to cook. Some toasters just have one cooking mode, while others have three, four, five or more cooking options for flexibility.

After studying hundreds of toaster oven reviews and doing some research of my own, I created this list of the top 10 toaster ovens to help you narrow down the options and select the right one for your kitchen.

10 Best Toaster Ovens To Buy For Kitchens Today in 2017

10. Proctor Silex 31118R 4-Slice Toaster Oven

If you want a toaster for basic tasks like heating up a frozen pizza and making toast, the Proctor Silex 31118R is a good buy. The most affordable model on this list of the best toaster ovens, it features a broil temperature setting, a bake mode and a toast mode.

Large enough to hold four slices of bread, the toaster has a 15-minute timer, a nice feature for a model in the entry-level price range A big drawback is that the crumb tray on this model is not removable. It just opens up like a hatch and empties the crumbs. This can make it hard to clean and a better option for people who only fire up the toaster occasionally.

Click HERE For Price!

9. Hamilton Beach 22708 Toastation 2-Slice Toaster and Mini Oven

The Hamilton Beach 22708 Toastation is a cross between a classic pop up toaster and a toaster oven, and it’s worthy of a spot on our list because it consistently gets good ratings in toaster oven reviews from customers. Designed to conserve space, it toasts in the top and bakes in the bottom.

The cooking area has enough room for two 16-inch slices of pizza to be baked side by side. Its knobs let you set the cooking mode and time, and there is a slide lever for setting the darkness of your toast, bagel or English muffin. The downside to this model is that if you were moving to a toaster oven in order to avoid having to deal with the pop-up mechanism on a classic toaster, this unit defeats the purpose.

Click HERE For Price!

8. Oster TSSTTVVG01 4-Slice Toaster Oven

The Oster TSSTTVVG01 is the little brother to the number one toaster on this list, and while it does not have the same impressive range of features, it’s value priced and a good choice for someone who wants a well-made appliance for basic cooking. You can toast, broil and bake with the model, and the inside has two rack positions for cooking foods of different heights.

A 30-minute timer gives you the ability to monitor cooking progress without having to reach for an egg timer or use the stove or microwave clock. While the toaster gets consistent praise in toaster oven reviews, the controls take some getting used to. Once you’ve mastered how to work it properly, the appliance is reportedly convenient.

Click HERE For Price!

7. Hamilton Beach 31334 Easy Reach Toaster Oven

The Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Toaster Oven looks a little different than most toaster ovens because it was developed with the solution to a common problem in mind–how to prevent burns when you’re taking food out of the toaster. Instead of a door that opens downwards, the door on this model rolls upwards, giving you clear access to the interior. This not only helps you get food in and out more safely, but it also allows for easy cleaning.

While this toaster is recommended for people who are most concerned with convenience, the rest of its features are rather basic. It only offers toast and bake settings, but its broiler fan does help to crisp crust on pizza. The biggest complaint about the model is that it’s noisy, as its dials tick away loudly while food cooks.

Click HERE For Price!

6. Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven 1800-Watt Toaster Oven with Element IQ

The Breville BOV800XL might have been able to make it to the top of this best of the best list if its price wasn’t so astronomical compared to other models on the market. It does offer nine cooking settings, including some unusual ones like Cookies and Reheat, but even when its advanced features are considered, it’s still overpriced. That said, you’ll be hard pressed to find a toaster that can brown bread more rapidly, as the model has five heating elements where most appliances only have two.

It also features a flashy LCD screen that goes from blue to orange while you’re cooking. This doesn’t really add a lot of value, but it makes the appliance look snazzy. The model uses a technology called Element IQ to self adjust its heating while food cooks to give you optimal results. This might not matter much if you’re just making toast, but if you want to bake, roast or broil a meal inside, the feature does come handy.

Click HERE For Price!

5. BLACK+DECKER TO1675B 6-Slice Toaster Oven

The BLACK+DECKER TO1675B has room for six slices of toast or a 9-inch pizza, making it roomy but not as oversized as some of the other six-piece models. It is tied for the longest timer of any model on the list, letting you set the heat for up to 60 minutes. The unit has convection, bake, broil, toast and keep warm functions and dual rack positions. Despite its nice range of features, the appliance comes in fifth primarily due to inconvenient features.

The crumb tray is a little harder to remove than some other models, and the design of the interior and lack of automatic pop-out racks increases the risk of accidental burns. On a final positive note, the toaster is less expensive than the other six-slice models on the countdown.

Click HERE For Price!

4. Waring TCO600 1500-Watt 6-Slice Convection Toaster Oven

Waring manufactures professional-grade appliances, and the Waring TCO600 reflects their commitment to quality while still being available for an economical price. This six-slice model has adjustable temperature settings from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and has a 60-minute timer like the Black and Decker in the fifth position. Its crumb tray slides out easily to simplify maintenance.

Toast browns quickly, thanks to the 1500-watt heating power, and the toaster has bake and broil options that work quite well. The biggest drawback to the unit is that its convection bake mode does not seem to provide the true benefits of convection cooking, which are evener heating and faster cooking times. Toaster oven reviews frequently state that there is no noticeable difference between the performance in convection bake and standard bake modes.

Click HERE For Price!

3. BLACK+DECKER TO1303SB 4-Slice Toaster Oven 

The BLACK+DECKER TO1303SB is the number one best-selling model on Amazon and is worthy of a high rank on any list of the best toaster ovens because of the number of features that it provides for the money. With Even Toast Technology, bread comes out evenly brown on all sides, and the model bakes, broils and roasts in addition to toasting.

An integrated 30-minute timer makes it easy to use the toaster for cooking, and it will keep food warm even after cooking is complete. The downside to this toaster is that it takes longer to toast than more expensive models on the market because it is less powerful. Also, there are reports of people accidentally getting burned when trying to remove their food because the inside is rather compact.

Click HERE For Price!

2. Cuisinart TOB-40N Custom Classic Toaster Oven/Broiler

Large in size and made out of stainless steel, the Cuisinart TOB-40N can fit an 11-inch pizza or 6 slices of toast with ease. Its knob controls let you set the level of darkness for toasting, select temperatures from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and cooking modes from four options: Toast, Bagel, Bake and Broil.

The inside has a nontoxic, nonstick coating that makes cleaning up after any cooking task a whole lot easier, and the racks slide out automatically for retrieving your food. Customers typically give the model good marks; however, there are many complaints that the markings on its dial are hard to see. If you have a small kitchen, the toaster may be too bulky for your space as well.

Click HERE For Price!

1. Oster TSSTTVMNDG Countertop 6-Slice Digital Convection Toaster Oven

The Oster Large Capacity TSSTTVMNDG Toaster has earned its spot as the best of the best toaster ovens because it allows you to cook nearly anything without having to fire up the oven or stove, and, it’s still one-fifth the price of the most expensive model on this list. Award winning, the toaster allows you to cook at temperatures between 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and has digital controls with an LCD clock display similar to what you find on microwaves.

There are seven cooking modes available, including a convection bake and a defrost. Its interior is illuminated, so you can check on the status of what you’re cooking, too. The biggest drawback of this toaster oven is its size, as it might be too large for more crowded kitchens.

Click HERE For Price!

Additional Buyers Guides

> Want to buy a toaster, click here.

> Want to buy an induction cooktop, click here.

> Want to buy a gas cooktop, click here.

Commonly Asked Questions and Other Requests

Who invented the toaster oven and what year?

The electric toaster and electric toaster oven was a product that originated from Scotland in the late 19th century. By the early 20th century, there was a patent that was put forward by Charles P. Strite. Some of the first automatic mechanics were starting to show up, and in the general publics homes.

How do you clean a toaster oven, properly?

You want to first unplug the power cord, make sure everything is cool to the touch, and remove all trays.

If possible, shake out all the crumbs and debris from inside. If not, manually collect everything until no remaining debris and crumbs are there. Next, go ahead and start scrubbing with a sponge. All the tough to remove areas, you can also use fine steel wool to scrub and polish out trays and interior.

We highly recommend an all purpose, non-toxic cleaner to take care of this process. The last part will be to dry off all the components. Turn on the toaster oven on a medium to high heat for 15-30 minutes to make sure any remaining cleaner that has not dried, will evaporate.

How to choose a toaster oven?

This part can be tricky, as there’s a few variables to look into.. before you make a decision. Here’s a few important things to consider:

  • Price
  • Cooking capacity
  • Verity of settings provided
  • Accessories included
  • Power consumption
  • Total size of the unit

Take any of these considerations into account, and from there you’re going to be able to choose the right toaster oven for yourself.

Common Foods Prepared Using a Toaster Oven

Pizza, baked eggs, baked potato, pastries, toast, quesadillas, kebabs, chicken tenders, salmon, and the list can go on for a LONG time. Most things you want to prepare in a conventional oven, you can do the same with a toaster oven.

How To Use A Toaster Oven

Pick a tray to use, lay down some foil, preheat the oven to the right temperature, place your uncooked meal, set appropriate timer to cook. There you go. Done.

Why Choose A Toaster Oven Over A Microwave?

While both are considered ovens, they do different things. Toaster ovens are used to… you guessed it, toast things (for the most part). While on the other hand, microwave ovens are used to heat things up in a VERY short period of time (we’re talking seconds here). Microwave ovens tend to kill nutrients in food, where as toaster ovens will not.

Microwaves are best for convenience, but toaster ovens can heat things up as well.. it just takes longer.

To be on the safe side, we recommend using the toaster oven for all purposes. You’ll get more nutritious, and thoroughly cooked food when its all said and done.

Top Rated Toaster Ovens Under Specific Price

Here’s the best under 200 dollars

Here we have the Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven as the best unit to buy under 200 dollars. It has a beautiful selection area, including a blue lcd screen showing you darkness and slice count. There’s plenty of power, and the capacity is around 0.45 cubic feet of space. Respectable for a “mini” series.

Here’s the best under 100 dollars

Here were stepping it up, and giving this unit a microwave look on the exterior. Unlike the cheaper products where there are selector dials, this one has digital buttons and a vast menu selection area. On top of that, it cooks 150-450 degrees, along with other things. At a reasonable 65 dollars, its respectable for what it is and something shoppers should have a look at.

Here’s the best under 50 dollars

If a simple toasting oven is what you’re looking for, than Black & Decker TO1203SB is what to look at. You get a durable exterior stainless steel finish, timer, temperature selection, mode selection, and trays. Under 25 dollars, you can’t go wrong. Especially since there’s over 2,300 individual user reviews giving it a 4+ star score.

Quick Video On How To Use Our #1 Pick Toaster Oven