Best Yogurt Makers 2017 – Buyer’s Guide

Although you can make high quality yogurt using a pot and a thermometer, many factors go into making it, and slightly off conditions lead to less than appetizing results. If you want to make delicious homemade yogurt, and avoid the risk of creating some kind of Franken-milk, a yogurt maker can take the guesswork out of the process.

Electric yogurt makers both simplify the steps and also speed up the procedure. Whereas ovens can take anywhere from 12-24 hours to ferment yogurt, a yogurt maker can produce a tasty product in as little as 8 hours.

All yogurt makers use some mechanism to incubate the yogurt mixture, thereby creating an ideal environment for the natural bacteria found in yogurt to multiply.

However, the best yogurt makers use the right amount of heat and temperature control to develop the finest consistency and taste every time.

While the procedure might sound like a complex science experiment, this guide can help you find the right appliance to make preparing a batch of delicious yogurt hassle-free.

If you’re new to the process of fixing up your own personalized jars of this dairy product, it might be hard to figure out what exactly you need in an electric yogurt maker.

Among the most important factors to consider are the amount of yogurt you’ll make, whether you want a multi-function or single function appliance, how often you plan on using it, and your price range. 

To ease the decision process, we’ve provided a list of yogurt maker reviews for the ten best products on the market.

Whatever your needs, you can refer to this guide for help locate the best yogurt maker for the money.

Top Products Reviewed

10. Tribest Yolife YL-210 Yogurt Maker

With two lids that allow you to make yogurt in different sized containers, the Tibest Yolife YL-210 Yogurt Maker is a good choice for anyone who occasionally makes large batches of yogurt. This device comes with seven 6-ounce jars, so that you can prepare individual portions. You can use these jars to make different flavors as well. What sets this yogurt maker apart from others on the market is that it allows you to make larger batches of yogurt. Simply use the high cover for serving sizes ranging from 1 quart to 80 ounces. It also features a timer that lets you know when the yogurt is done.

Despite the range of options the Yolife YL-210 can give, there is one design flaw that can hinder the performance of this machine. Many yogurt maker reviews report that the machine overheats, reaching temperatures of 128, or even 136, degrees. Since ideal temperatures for yogurt cultures are around 105-110 degrees, the model’s potential to overheat can make it difficult to get the right consistency for the yogurt. For this reason, we recommend this product for those who are willing to observe the yogurt maker and adjust the temperature as needed.

9. T-fal YG232 Balanced Living Yogurt Maker

Those who love to eat yogurt, and enjoy the convenience and control a yogurt maker gives, may find the T-fal YG23 Balanced Living Yogurt Marker to be a sleek addition to the kitchen. This product comes with seven individual portion glass jars that pair with adjustable date code lids, allowing you to keep track of your yogurt’s freshness. The innovative design is tailor made with user convenience in mind, with features like a reversible lid that can also serve as a storage container. The LCD countdown timer and digital controls are also simple to operate and ease to use. If you like making different flavors, you’ll enjoy the variety of recipes that come with this model. The ability to set the timer from anywhere between 8 to 15 hours also helps you prepare yogurt of the most ideal consistency for you. 

One of the best features of this yogurt maker is the automatic shut off, which immediately powers down the device after the set time has elapsed.  This ensures that the yogurt doesn’t get overcooked, making it an ideal choice for any one who is too busy to monitor the maker.  The only major flaw with the maker is the cleaning difficulty, especially in harder to reach areas like the inner rim of the glass jars.

8. Salton YM9 1-Quart Yogurt Maker

If you like whipping up big batches of yogurt often, then the Salton YM9 1-Quart yogurt maker is a perfect machine for you. With a quart sized container that’s easy to clean and freezer safe, this model has the capacity to function as both a yogurt maker and a frozen yogurt maker. The straightforward design and easy operation make this model user-friendly. You can also tuck the cord away in the maker’s base for easy storage.

While this machine is well crafted, durable, and great at making yogurt, there are few drawbacks considering the price. This product comes with a manual dial instead of a timer. The dial doesn’t emit any alarm sounds so you’ll have to keep tabs on your yogurt as it cooks. The lack of an on/off switch is also slightly inconvenient since users have to pull the plug to turn the machine off.

7. Oster CKSTYM1012 Mykonos Greek Digital Yogurt Maker

The Oster CKSTYM1012 Mykonos Greek Yogurt Maker is designed for yogurt aficionados who want prepare this delicious treat in different sizes, without having to pay for extra containers and lids. This model includes 6 glass jars with covers, a large plastic container, and a strainer for making Greek yogurt. For great tasting and fresh Greek yogurt, you simply have follow three easy steps: mix, cook, and strain. You can also freeze the containers, allowing this model to work as a frozen yogurt maker as well. Long lasting and durable, this maker is a good option for anyone who makes yogurt at home on a weekly basis.

Unlike other yogurt makers, this machine is missing some convenience features. The most inconvenient factor of the product is that it doesn’t have a timer, which can be problematic for extremely busy or forgetful users. Since it’s a newer model, it’s important to note that there aren’t any replacement or accessory parts available, making it less user-friendly than many competitors on the market. Some yogurt maker reviews have also reported that the manual can be vague at times, so this product isn’t ideal for a first time buy.

6. Yogourmet Electric Yogurt Maker

The Yogourmet Electric Yogurt Maker is designed for making large batches of yogurt in nearly half the time it takes competitors. In just as little as 4 ½ hours, you can make 2 quarts of yogurt. We recommend this model to newbie yogurt chefs because it comes with a detailed instruction manual and accessories such as a cheese strainer and thermometer. The Yogourmet yogurt maker is unique because it uses a “water bath” system that develops an even heat temperature around the inner container.

What this product lacks in high tech gadgetry, it makes up for in functionality and versatility. If convenience is a big factor for you, then you’ll like the flexibility that this product provides. You can buy separate containers so that you can make more yogurt of varying flavors. There are some downsides to this product, such as fact that the lids can occasionally shoot off during the cooking process, resulting in big messes. Another issue is that the model struggles to keep the exact temperature needed for properly made yogurt, and can heat up to about 120 degrees. This means that it needs continuous observation and may require the user to disconnect the maker if it gets too hot.

5. Vonshef Electric Yogurt Maker

Stylish and inexpensive, the Vonshef Electric Yogurt Maker is great for making multiple flavors of yogurt in one session. With a temperature range of 110-113 degrees Fahrenheit, you’re guaranteed to have properly prepared yogurt of any consistency you prefer. The maker is also only 15 watts, so it’s ideal for anyone on budget.

This model scores high on quality. Its 7oz glass jars are well made and its stainless steel exterior also makes it a good fit for any kitchen. The only drawback to this maker is that it doesn’t feature a timer, so it might not be the best yogurt maker for individuals who can’t check the yogurt’s progress frequently. For it’s quality build and design this is the best yogurt maker for the money if you’re looking for a good deal.

4. Epica Homemade Organic “Set and Go” Electric Yogurt Maker

The Epica Homemade Organic “Set and Go” Electric Yogurt Maker lives up to its name. After an easy and quick prep, you simply set the timer and go. The automatic temperature control also removes the hassle of having to fuss with a thermometer throughout the process. This model is also compact, allowing for easy storage on your kitchen counters or in cupboards.

One thing that is missing from this unit is an automatic shut off, making it slightly inconvenient if you like set the yogurt maker before bed.  The timer doesn’t signal when the machine is done, which means that you have to remember when to turn it off. 

3. Dash Greek Yogurt Maker

Designed with user convenience in mind, the Dash Greek Yogurt maker features concealed cord storage, a LCD display, and a traditional timer. It also has an automatic shut off feature, so it’s perfect for first time yogurt makers and those who’d rather set the maker and not worry about it until it’s done.

While the straining procedure in the process of making Greek yogurt is often messy, the Dash yogurt maker is created to avoid the mess. It comes with a serving container that features a strainer, making the process easy and less time consuming. However, since the strainer is on the smaller side, users will have to dump out the serving jar periodically as the yogurt drains. 

2. Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker

With a built in cooling system, easy operation, and state of the art design, the Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker is the best yogurt maker for the money. The stainless steel design and accessible time controls make this a great choice for people who make homemade yogurt often. Among the most convenient features of this machine are the countdown timer and automatic cooling, which will start the cooling process after the yogurt cooks completely.

Another functional attribute of this model is that it allows you to prepare the yogurt mixture without having to preheat the milk. This time saving feature means there’s less work and clean up for the user. The maker also has the capacity to cook 50 oz, which is ideal for people who depend on yogurt in cooking or baking as well for snacks or meals.   

1. Euro Cuisine YMX650 Automatic Digital Yogurt Maker

The Euro Cuisine YMX650 Automatic Digital Yogurt Maker scores high on convenience, quality manufacturing, and capacity. Given 4.5 stars by yogurt maker reviews on Amazon, the Euro Cuisine YMX650 has a digital countdown timer, additional jar storage, and 3-year warranty. It has the ability to make 42 oz of yogurt in one session, which can easily be done with the 7 standard glass jars that comes with the model. You can also adjust the dates on the lids to help you keep track of the yogurt’s freshness.

The only real flaw associated with this machine is that the temperatures inside the maker can occasionally get a little too hot for ideal yogurt making. Defective models might cause this problem, and users should consider contacting the manufacturer if the issue persists. In most cases, however, the temperature doesn’t rise above 110 degrees.

Best yogurt maker under 200

For the best yogurt maker under 200 dollars, we chose the T-fal YG232 Balanced Living Yogurt Maker. Backed by a 1-year warranty, this maker is both user-friendly and versatile. The model is also built using high quality materials and prepares delicious yogurt with perfect consistency.

Best yogurt maker under 100

The best yogurt maker under 100 dollars is by far the Cuisinart CYM-100 Electric Yogurt Maker. Its automatic cooling system makes it perfect for having fresh, ready to eat yogurt in nearly half the time by allowing you to skip the refrigeration process. This is the perfect product if you want to let your yogurt ferment over night and have fully prepared yogurt for breakfast in the morning.

Best yogurt maker under 50

If you’re looking for the best yogurt maker under 50 dollars, we recommend the Dash Greek Yogurt maker. The maker can produce both regular yogurt and Greek yogurt. The several different color combinations you can select for this model also make it a fun and personalized addition to your kitchen. For less than 50 dollars, you get more functionality compared to many yogurt makers that cost nearly twice as much, making this the best yogurt maker for the money.

How to use a yogurt maker

The great thing about yogurt makers is that they’re ease to operate and take all the stress out of creating a temperate environment for the bacteria cultures.

While you should always follow the directions that come with your particular product, most yogurt makers are designed with the same general procedure in mind.

You can control the settings on your maker by using the start, stop, and timer features. From this control panel you can set the device to work for the amount of time needed to transform your milk into yogurt.

Keep in mind that the number of hours needed to prepare delicious yogurt can vary depending on the kind of milk you use.

How to make yogurt in a yogurt maker

Thanks to your yogurt maker, great tasting, unprocessed yogurt is simply a touch of a button away.

The process is relatively easy and even fun. To whip up a batch of the healthy and satisfying snack, simply follow these steps:

Begin by preheating the maker. While the device is heating, boil the milk of your choice.

With most yogurt makers you can use any kind of milk, including non-dairy milks like soy or almond.

After the milk begins to boil, remove from heat and let cool. Using a candy thermometer check that the milk has reached the right temperature, around 100 degrees.

Then add your starter yogurt or starter culture. Stir thoroughly.

Once your have your yogurt mixture ready to go, pour into containers. Place the containers in the yogurt maker, and secure the lid onto the maker.

Adjust the timer as needed, and let the yogurt cook. Typically, this phase can take anywhere between 8-12 hours.

When the timer is finished, simply remove the lid, stir the yogurt, and cap. Refrigerate for 3-4 hours.

Serve with any toppings and flavors you like.

How to clean a yogurt maker

When it comes to cleaning your yogurt maker, the process should be nearly effortless. Although all yogurt makers will comes with their own set of cleaning instructions, you’ll find that more often than not, the only things that requires consistent cleaning are the containers and lids that come with your maker. 

Most makers feature dishwasher safe jars that make cleaning in between preparation cycles a breeze.

Smaller or narrower jars can be difficult to wash because they feature harder to reach nooks and crannies. You can bypass this problem by letting the jars soak in lukewarm water over night.

Who invented the yogurt maker?

While it’s estimated that yogurt has been around for over 5000 years, the household yogurt maker appeared on the market in the 1970s.

There’s some debate about who invented the yogurt maker. However, among the first U.S. patents is a model created by inventor George Castanis, which used heated tap water to prepare yogurt.

How a yogurt maker works

Remember, quality yogurt must be cooked for several hours in temperatures of about 110 degrees.

These specific temperatures are required to foster the cultivation of the bacteria necessary to transform milk into yogurt. Anything above 110 degrees can actually kill the bacteria, which hinders the yogurt from setting properly.

This can be a difficult effect to achieve in a conventional oven since it requires you to consistently monitor the yogurt’s temperature over a period of 12-15 hours.

Yogurt makers are designed to reach and maintain these temperatures over long periods of time. They create an incubated and controlled environment for the yogurt to cook, meaning that they require less supervision.

Their trademark ability to maintain the ideal temperatures for yogurt preparation also means that they can cook the yogurt a bit faster, with most models usually taking about 8-12 hours. 

What are different things you can make with a yogurt maker?

Another beneficial aspect to having a yogurt maker is that many models are multi-function appliances.

Other than using your maker to cook different flavors of yogurt, you can also use it to make herb infused oils, non-dairy yogurts, and even quark cheese.

Depending on the model you purchase, your yogurt maker can also be used to cook other dairy products as well, including cheese, buttermilk and sour cream.

Some machines also have the ability to function as a frozen yogurt maker. Others can be used as a pressure cooker for rice or Japanese Natto.